|
|
Co-operative
small group learning is an approach to organising classroom activity so that
pupils can interact with and learn from each other as well as the teacher
and the world around them. Various names have been given to this form of
teaching: co-operative learning, collaborative learning, collective
learning, learning communities, peer teaching and peer learning. But all in
all, there are three general types of group work: informal learning groups,
formal learning groups and study teams.
Points Arising from Research
 |
Pupils working in small groups tend to learn more
of what is taught and retain it longer than when the same content is presented
in other instructional formats |
 |
Pupils also appear more satisfied with their
classes |
 |
This learning fosters stronger feelings of
self-worth |
 |
Pupils feel accepted by peers and more able to learn
|
 |
Pupils assume greater responsibility for their
actions and develop co-operative skills |
 |
They learn values such as respect and caring for
others, responsibility, helpfulness and empathy. It is important that learners have specific
opportunities to work co-operatively as groups rather than simply in
groups and are encouraged to do so |
Key Elements of Co-operative Learning
Discipline/class management issues
 |
Pupils
need to be given a considerable amount of freedom to work through tasks, with
relatively infrequent intervention by the teacher |
 |
Pupils need to
develop responsible attitudes to this kind of work, since such skills are
extremely important in the world of work |
 |
By circulating from
group to group, the teacher can maintain a presence in the activity, showing
interest in pupils’ progress |
 |
In such an
environment, pupils’ interest in the task is an important element in motivation |
 |
Providing clear
structure to group tasks is important |
 |
Pupils usually
arrive in Secondary schools familiar with group work approaches |
Size of group
 |
A group of
three is small enough to encourage each individual to participate fully. The
lines of communication are fairly simple |
 |
A group of four
can provide a good balance of views, knowledge and skills |
 |
With a group of
five or more the lines of communication may become too complex, individuals
may easily opt out, or the group may in practice split into a pair and a
threesome |
 |
The less
skilful the group members, the smaller the groups should be |
 |
The shorter
the time available, the smaller the groups should be |
Composition of groups
 |
Low attainment
groups may require a great deal of support. Individuals may not gain much
from other members and there may be little collaborative discussion |
 |
High attaining
pupils may proceed quickly and explore in depth but don’t assume they have
effective co-operating skills or that there are no benefits for them in
mixed attainment groupings |
 |
Mixed
attainment groups enhance the self-esteem of low attainers and provide
opportunities for high attainers to explain ideas, organise investigation
etc. |
 |
Decide how
groups will be formed - e.g. self-selection or pupils can express a
preference and teacher makes the final decisions |
 |
Give pupils the
opportunity to experience a variety of groupings as individual learning
strengths and difficulties can become apparent |
Teacher’s role
 |
Clearly explain
the broad goals and objectives |
 |
Create group
tasks that require interdependence |
 |
Create
assignments that fit the pupils’ skills and abilities by assigning
relatively easy tasks at first and increasing the difficulty level as pupils
become more knowledgeable |
 |
Assign group tasks
that allow each group member to make an equal contribution and
ensure that there is a fair division of labour |
 |
Create an
environment where there are plenty opportunities for learners to talk, and
where they feel safe to share their emerging ideas and incomplete
understandings |
 |
The teacher
adopts a facilitating role, managing resources and overseeing progress |
Training in co-operative skills
Specific skills need to be discussed, modelled and reinforced
such as:
 |
active and
tolerant listening |
 |
helping one
another in mastering content |
 |
giving and
receiving constructive criticism |
 |
managing
disagreement
|
Other examples of co-operative skills are:
 |
Contributing
ideas |
 |
Staying on task |
 |
Summarising for
understanding |
 |
Asking
questions |
 |
Expressing
support |
 |
Showing
appreciation |
Pupils need specific instructions about
kinds of
co-operation, e.g. one person to record results and another to check the
answer etc.
Assessing group work
 |
Interviews
after the task is completed |
 |
Video or
tape-record the group at work |
 |
Observe the
group at work |
Reflection and Discussion
Which areas of the above do you recognise in your current
school/classroom practice?
Are there any strategies that you would consider adopting to
encourage co-operative small group learning in your school/classroom?
|
Some Activities Relating To
the Issue of Co-operative Learning |
|
Key element |
Objective |
Action |
|
|
Some examples and
suggestions |
|
Discipline/class management
issues
|
Pupils usually arrive in
Secondary schools familiar with group work approaches |
Consider how your approach with
S1/2 matches with what your pupils experienced in their Primary
schools. Do they have skills on which you can capitalise? Try
asking them what they think about Primary/Secondary approaches. |
|
Composition of group |
Ensure that children experience
working alongside a range of others. |
Rainbow Groups: Give each pupil
in a group a number, or a colour. When the group has worked
together, all the pupils of the same number or colour form new
groups to compare what they have done.
|
|
Teacher’s role
|
Create an environment where
there are plenty of opportunities for learners to work together. |
Arrange resources so that they
are easily accessed by pupils themselves and that there are areas
set aside for small group working. |
|
Training in co-operative
skills |
Giving pupils an opportunity to
express understanding, and to respond to the views of others in a
supportive way. |
Twos to fours or snowballing.
Pupils work in pairs then join
with another pair to explain what they have achieved, and to compare
this with the work of the other pair. |
|
Assessment |
Group members assess their
collaborative efforts and target improvements |
Give spot quizzes to be
completed individually and calling on individual pupils to present
their group’s progress. |
Selected References

Further Reading
The following are suggested as starting points. They contain references to
other work, which could be useful.
Davies, B.G.(1993) Collaborative Learning: Group Work and Study Teams
from ‘Tool For Teaching’ Jossey-Bass Publishers: San Francisco
Hopkins, D. & Harris, A. (2000) Creating the conditions for Teaching
and Learning. David Fulton Publishers
Ngeow, K. (1998) Enhancing Student Thinking through Collaborative
Learning ERIC Digest ERIC Identifier: ED422586
Panitz, T. (1996) Collaborative Learning: Some points for discussion
Deliberations
http://www.londonmet.ac.uk/deliberations/collaborative-learning/panitz-discussion/
SCCC (1996) Teaching for Effective Learning. Dundee SCCC
SCCC Developing Co-operative Groupwork Math 5-14 Exemplification
SCCC (1998) Working With Others
Tinzmann, M.B. et al(1990) What Is The Collaborative Classroom? North
Central Regional Educational Laboratory.
info@ncrel.org

Websites
Searches for “Cooperative Learning” will produce a
variety of results such as:
http://www-acad.sheridanc.on.ca/scls/coop/cooplrn.htm
Site of the Canada-based Cooperative Learning Network, which provides
a number of links. The site draws attention to the name of Spencer Kagan,
who is associated with developments in this area.
www.learntolearn.ac.uk/
Associated with the Cambridge University Education Dept, this
site offers material of a general nature, which might be found helpful in
the current context.
|