|
|
Managing pupil behaviour is
not simply about responding to inappropriate behaviour, but about creating
conditions which will encourage positive behaviour.
Points Arising
from Research
 |
Factors contributing
to good behaviour in schools include:
-
a
whole-school approach
-
high
expectations
-
warm
teacher-pupil relationships
-
a
high-profile head-teacher
-
class
teachers taking key responsibility
-
good
communication with the local community
|
 |
Persistent low-level disruption is reported as the most serious cause of stress
to teachers |
 |
A 1999-2000 Scottish survey showed that 82% of pupils excluded were boys (see
Toolkit on Gender |
 |
Looked-after children are 13 times more likely to be
excluded than others |
 |
Excluded pupils tend to show characteristics such as:
-
poor
basic skills
-
limited aspirations
-
poor interpersonal relationships
-
susceptibility to negative peer pressure
-
parents/carers who are unable to
control them
-
having been victims of physical/sexual abuse
-
experience of
racism.
|
Key Elements of Behaviour Management
Understanding behaviour:
 |
Teachers can get to know
pupils’ backgrounds to make personal connections with them |
 |
Emotional Intelligence
is important (see Toolkit section on
Emotional Intelligence). Highland uses the
“Lessons for
Living” programme for upper Primary and lower Secondary pupils |
 |
Teachers can benefit
from seeing a discipline situation from different perspectives |
 |
Audits of behaviour
patterns can be used to identify key problems |
 |
“Framework For
Intervention” (developed in Highland as the “Structured Intervention
Approach”) involves auditing the learning and teaching environment to try to
understand what might be contributing to inappropriate behaviour |
 |
Pupils, parents and
teachers need to be aware of individuals’ rights and responsibilities |
 |
Positive behaviour can
be coached, as can strategies to work on challenging behaviour
|
Learning
and teaching:
 |
Teaching should be
interesting and varied and offer pupils a degree of choice |
 |
Account should be taken of
pupils’ preferred
learning styles (see Toolkit on
Learning Styles) |
 |
Pupils should feel involved
in the learning and teaching process |
 |
Well organised, purposeful
cooperative learning activities can improve behaviour (mixed sex groups can
be good) |
 |
Expectations should be
regularly reinforced and should be realistic but challenging |
 |
Teaching should encourage
an accurate match between aspirations and ability |
 |
When pupils feel that they
are succeeding they are less likely to be disaffected |
 |
Celebration of success of
all kinds should be a part of classroom and school life |
 |
Lack of challenge in S1/2
can lead to boredom, which can contribute to poor behaviour |
 |
Effective use of ICT can
contribute towards good behaviour |
Teacher
behaviour:
 |
The teacher’s every word
and action should be based on the assumption that
all pupils can achieve whatever is to be learned |
 |
Teachers should be alert
and show that they know what is going on in the classroom |
 |
Work should be organised in
a smooth but brisk way with clear appropriate deadlines |
 |
Inattentive pupils can be
questioned to bring them back on track |
 |
Physical proximity to
unsettled pupils can help (but avoid approaching from behind) |
 |
Involving pupils in aspects
of classroom management can help |
 |
Using humour has been shown
to have a beneficial effect on pupil attitudes |
 |
Praise and reinforcement of
effort/strategies/success are important, but should be dependent on
performance and used with discrimination, so that pupils value them |
 |
Simple non-verbal
encouragement (smile, thumbs-up etc) is effective |
 |
Teachers should model good
behaviour patterns and be aware of their own stress control techniques |
 |
When pupils arrive in the
classroom, initial contacts should be positive |
 |
Behaviour can be discussed
with whole class and those meriting rewards identified |
 |
An instruction forbidding
something should be phrased positively and constructively |
 |
Certain behaviours might be
ignored if they will not damage the work of the class |
 |
Accusations should be
avoided |
 |
It is not necessary to
punish for inappropriate behaviour immediately |
 |
The
certainty of consequences is more important than their severity |
Assertive discipline (Favoured by many, but not universally accepted):
 |
Pupils learn to
choose
responsible behaviour, to raise self esteem and improve academic success |
 |
Teachers ‘lead’ their
classes in a calm, assertive, consistent and supportive manner |
 |
A classroom discipline plan
is taught and frequently referred to |
 |
Rewards/sanctions are
clearly explained and used |
 |
Pupils enjoy stability in
their everyday working environment |
 |
There is close home
contact, of a positive nature, not just negative |
 |
The Assertive Discipline
system gives concrete suggestions for managing behaviour |
Whole-school issues:
 |
Discipline paper-work
should be easily managed |
 |
It should also be
constructed in a positive way, and not simply be about negatives |
 |
Buddy, mentoring and
“peer-mediation” have been successful |
 |
Rules, rewards and
sanctions should be: stated positively; clear and specific; few and
comprehensive; understood by all pupils; frequently reinforced in a positive
way; devised in consultation with pupils (and parents?) |
 |
It is important to have
good contacts with the home, children’s centres and carers |
 |
Parents/carers can be
involved through behaviour contracts and regular arranged communications |
 |
All teachers should be
aware of the work of the school’s pupil support systems, including the roles
of those who have not traditionally been part of school life |
 |
Providing more flexibility
in the curriculum (especially related to pupils’ goals/aspirations) can
improve behaviour |
 |
Problems of reduced
motivation in S1/2 need to be addressed |
 |
Effective bullying policies
are important - pupils need to feel safe |
 |
Schools may become involved
in schemes to teach parenting (see references below) |
 |
Teachers should maintain a
high profile outside the classroom in monitoring behaviour |
 |
When sanctions are applied
they should be seen to be appropriate to the misbehaviour, effective and
should be accompanied by support for future improvement |
 |
Absenteeism is a key area
to tackle in promoting positive attitudes |
 |
Teachers should be
supported in a non-judgemental way |
Reflection
and Discussion
To what
extent do you recognise the above principles in your own work?
Are there any
areas which you might address in your classroom or the whole-school context?
|
Some
Activities Relating to the Issue of Behaviour Management |
|
Key element |
Objective |
Action |
|
|
Some examples and suggestions |
|
Understanding behaviour
|
Framework for Intervention |
Find out about the FFI system. Better Behaviour – Better Learning (see
references below) contains information on this, along with a case study. Does this strategy have any potential for the individual class teacher? Is there
scope for following this up on a whole-school basis? Secondary teachers can find out about Circle Time and Golden Rules in Primaries. |
|
Learning and teaching |
When pupils feel that they are succeeding…. |
Take time to consider how each of the pupils in a class may regard their achievements.
A questionnaire can be used for this. Can you reinforce the successes that individuals have had – even, perhaps, out-of-school success. What do you know
about pupils’ out-of-school achievements? |
|
Teacher behaviour
|
Initial contacts should be positive |
Make a point of speaking to individuals as they enter the classroom, making a positive
comment. Try to make such contact with all pupils at some point, based on some personal feature of their lives/work. |
|
Assertive discipline |
Assertive discipline is a structured approach |
Find out more about how Assertive Discipline works, perhaps following up some of the
suggestions in the references below. Evaluate this approach, considering particularly the rewards element and whether/how this might be implemented. |
|
Whole-school issues |
Good home contacts are important
|
Consider the extent to which your pupils’ parents/carers are involved in proactive
behavioural support. Is there scope for sending home more positive news about pupils’ behaviour, in terms both of individuals’ situations and of school
policies/strategies. What concrete role can parents/carers play in prevention of bad behaviour? |
Selected References

Further Reading
Guidelines on Supporting and Managing Positive Behaviour in Schools – Highland policy
Teaching with Influence by Peter Hook and Andy Vass Publ:
David Fulton
Creating Winning Classrooms by Peter Hook and Andy Vass Publ: David Fulton
Emotional Intelligence by Daniel Goleman Publ: Bloomsbury
Behaviour Management: A Whole-school Approach by Bill Rogers Publ: Paul Chapman
Cracking the Hard Class: Strategies for Managing the Harder Than Average Class
by Bill Rogers
Publ: Paul Chapman
Video titles by Bill Rogers: Repair and Rebuild; Prevention; Managing Behaviour: Positive Correction; Managing Behaviour: Consequences; Decisive Discipline.
Incentive Plus catalogue – Excellent resources (Tel.01908 526120;
www.incentiveplus.co.uk
)
CD Rom: Dealing With Disruption – Scottish Executive funded resource which was distributed to
schools in 2002. Interactive resource giving advice and guidance on managing disruption. Includes video/audio clips, printable resources and suggested reading.

Websites
www.inclusive-solutions.com
English-based site which offers a lot of practical support
www.users.globalnet.co.uk/~ebdstudy/interven.htm
Extremely thorough analysis/advice, including behaviour profiling (with an example), information on teaching parenting and
material on self-esteem and social skills
www.disciplinehelp.com/
Identifies well over 100 specific types of pupil behaviour and gives suggestions as to how to deal with them
www.ltscotland.org.uk/wholeschoolissues/index.asp
gives access to:
www.scotland.gov.uk/library3/education/rdtg.pdf
This site provides a downloadable version of the document Better Behaviour - Better Learning, the
important 2001 report of the Scottish Discipline Task Group
www.nwrel.org/scpd/sirs/5/cu9.html
A 2001 American review of research on school discipline and behaviour strategies
www.adprima.com/assertive.htm - a balanced view of Lee and Marlene Canter’s work on Assertive Discipline.
The following contains an explanation of Assertive Discipline:
http://maxweber.hunter.cuny.edu/pub/eres/EDSPC715_MCINTYRE/AssertiveDiscipline.html
|