|
|
People learn in
different ways. When an individual’s learning style is identified, that has
implications for the best ways in which to present and process information.
There are many ways of analysing learning styles - this paper will
concentrate on the most popular, focusing on the VAK analysis.
[See also the section on Howard Gardner’s theory of Multiple Intelligences]
Points Arising from Research
 |
A teacher’s own
learning style may influence how he/she teaches and this may not be
readily compatible with some pupils’ learning styles. |
 |
Teaching is most
effective when it matches the pupils’ learning style preferences. |
 |
Estimates vary
as to the proportion of the population with particular learning
style preferences, but one estimate has the kinaesthetic style as
the most common. |
 |
Gender has an
important bearing on learning styles: for example, boys are more
likely to have a kinaesthetic preference. |
 |
Cultural and
environmental factors can influence an individual’s learning
preferences. |
 |
Identifying
learning styles can be of particular importance in catering for
pupils with learning difficulties. |
 |
For lifelong
learning, it is important that pupils come to understand what their
learning preferences are and learn strategies for exploiting this. |
Key Elements of Learning Styles
How the brain works
 |
The two
hemispheres of the brain work in different ways, though normally
both sides are involved almost all the time. |
 |
The left
(“logical”) side is dominant in sequencing, processing mathematical
information, using language, processing unrelated factual
information etc. |
 |
The right
(“gestalt”) side is dominant in responding to music, appreciating
spatial relationships, understanding forms and patterns, being
creative etc. |
 |
In boys the
right brain tends to be dominant; in girls the left brain. |
 |
The educational
system has traditionally favoured left brain activities such as
reading, writing and listening. |
 |
Teachers are
typically likely to be left brain dominant and this may affect the
way they teach. |
 |
Classroom
activities should be devised to cater satisfactorily for both left
and right brain thinkers. |
 |
Some activities
develop the use of both sides of the brain. |
Kolb’s theory
 |
The work of Kolb
and others produced the classification of learners into four groups:
ACTIVISTS, REFLECTORS, THEORISTS and PRAGMATISTS |
 |
Activists like
practical work such as labs, field work, observation exercises and
using visual source material for information etc |
 |
Reflectors like
to learn by watching others, by taking time to consider observations
of their own experience etc |
 |
Theorists like
lectures, reading papers on topics, considering analogies etc |
 |
Pragmatists like
simulations, case studies, homework etc |
 |
Thus the four
types might approach the learning of a software programme in
different ways: |
- Activists might just start
using it and feel their way into it
- Reflectors might have a go at
using it and then take time to think about what they have just done
- Theorists might begin by
reading the manual
- Pragmatists might start using
the programme, but make frequent references to the Help files.
 |
The four types
of learning can be seen as cyclical stages through which a learner
can progress (Watch>>>Think>>>Feel>>>Do), as well as
categorising specific kinds of learning experience. |
McCarthy’s 4MAT analysis
 |
This developed the notion of a
cycle through which the learner progresses in a classroom topic or block of
work. It made use of left/right brain science |
 |
Learners are classified as
Innovative, Analytical, Common Sense, or Dynamic. |
 |
The cycle of learning is as
follows: concrete experience>>>reflective observation>>>abstract conceptualisation>>>active experimentation |
 |
Teachers can build activities
to provide pupils with a sequence of activities which allows for this sort of
progress. |
VAK (developed from
Neuro-Linguistic Programming research, or NLP)
The most popular
analysis identifies three learning styles: Visual, Auditory and Kinaesthetic
(sometimes the “a” is missed out of “kinaesthetic”). Sometimes Kinaesthetic
is said to include “Tactile” learning and sometimes this is added as a
separate learning style. Some analysts add Read/write to make VARK and some
subdivide the Visual and Auditory categories into verbal- and non-verbal.
 |
Any individual
will operate in all three “modalities”, but with a preference for
one or two. |
 |
Visual learners
are likely to prefer mind-maps, diagrams, picturesque language, flow
charts, use of colour, white space on the page etc. |
 |
Auditory
learners are likely to prefer discussion, explaining things to
others, using a tape recorder, teaching linked to anecdotes/jokes
etc. |
 |
Kinaesthetic
learners are likely to prefer group work, using models/objects in
describing things, walking around while learning, hands-on
activities, books with strong plot etc. |
 |
Teachers should
be aware of their own VAK preferences. |
 |
Pupils should be
made aware of their individual preferences: |
-
Physiological cues can help
identify type
-
Linguistic cues can also be
used
-
Self-test materials can be
used
 |
Since boys are
likely to be kinaesthetic learners and since they have been catered
for least in the traditional curriculum, and since boys tend to
under-perform, it may be worth concentrating on the K area. |
 |
Parents can be
made aware of pupils’ learning preferences. |
 |
Pupils should be
encouraged to develop strategies for independent use, related to
their learning styles, thus promoting lifelong learning. |
Reflection and Discussion
To what extent does your
teaching provide a range of activities in the VAK sense?
Do any of the other
theories (and there are plenty more to research) strike any chords?
What opportunities do
you see to enhance the range of types of activity in your classroom?
|
Some Activities Relating To
the Issue of Learning Styles |
|
Key element |
Objective |
Action |
|
|
Some examples and
suggestions |
|
How the brain works |
Classroom activities should be devised to cater satisfactorily for both
left and right brain thinkers. |
In preparing a block of work, try to devise activities for both left and
right brain thinkers. Mike Hughes (for example) gives suggestions as to
how some activities can connect the two sides of the brain. |
|
Kolb’s theory |
Activists, Reflectors, Theorists and Pragmatists |
Consider whether your teaching provides active participation (for
activists), is intellectually satisfying (for theorists), is practical
(for pragmatists), is leisurely (for reflectors). |
|
4MAT |
Teachers can build activities to provide pupils with a sequence of
activities which allows for this sort of progress. |
Using one block of work, consider the structure of
activities. Can McCarthy’s cycle be of use here? Accelerated
Learning in the Classroom gives consideration to developing this
model of teaching. |
|
VAK |
Pupils should be made aware of their individual preferences: |
Carry out a survey (there are plenty online and in books -
Accelerated Learning in the Classroom for example) and discuss
with the class. Does your teaching match with the preferences in your
class. What about a whole department/school survey? What about a staff
survey? Have pupils draw up a list of strategies which would be
appropriate for their own preferences. |
|
|
Kinaesthetic learners are likely to prefer….
|
Can you find opportunities to include more physical activity in your
lessons? Maths teachers can have pupils with bits of equations on cards
at the front of the class, moving around to put the cards in the right
order. Chemistry teachers can have pupils mime a chemical reaction. In
History scenes can be acted out….. |
Selected References

Further Reading
Smith, A (1996)
Accelerated Learning in the Classroom, Network Educational Press. ISBN: 1
85539 034 5
Smith’s books
give very good introductions to the theories about learning styles, along
with very concrete suggestions as to how this information might influence
classroom practice. This book is particularly easy to read.
Smith, A (1999)
Accelerated Learning in Practice ,Network Educational Press. ISBN: 1 85539
048 5
Hughes, M (1999)
Closing the Learning Gap.ISBN: 1855390515
Gives a very
clear, accessible explanation of theories, along with very practical
suggestions re classroom practice.

Websites
A number of websites
contain advice for FE and HE students as to learning styles, giving explicit
advice on strategies they should adopt to learn more effectively. This sort
of advice can be helpful in thinking about how school pupils work. See the
support4learning website below.
www.support4learning.org.uk/education/learning_styles.cfm
Gives many links to
related sites. Follow the link to VARK, for example, where there is advice
to college students about learning styles.
www.chaminade.org/inspire/learnstl.htm
Offers self-assessment
of learning styles.
Searches for the
following will lead to further interesting material:
Kolb; Honey
and Mumford; McCarthy |